Sibling Rivalry is Rarely About the Toy

2 mins read
By: Guest Author |
Sibling Rivalry is Rarely About the Toy

I have three children, and I can tell you the fight is almost never about the toy. 

It's about who got more of me today. Who was noticed. Who felt like they mattered a bit less at 4pm when everyone was tired and hungry and the house was loud. 

For a long time, I refereed. I'd walk in, work out who had it first, hand down a verdict and walk out. It never worked. The same fight came back twenty minutes later wearing a different outfit. 

Here is what I do now. 

1. I stopped being the judge. 
Unless someone is physically unsafe, I stay out of the verdict. I name what I see ("you both want the same thing") and hand it back to them. Slowly, they've started solving it without me. 

2. I treat the fight as information. 
A child who keeps picking at a sibling is usually telling me something. They're tired, or they need me close, or they've had a hard day at school and the only safe place to put it is at home. So I ask myself what they need before I ask who started it. 

3. I deal with hitting calmly and quickly. 
Hitting is a phase for most children, not a character flaw. I separate them, keep my voice low, and say one clear sentence: "I won't let you hurt your sister." Then I check on the one who was hurt first. The conversation about feelings comes later, when everyone can actually hear it. 

4. No comparisons. No labels. 
"Why can't you be more like your brother" has never helped anyone. Neither has "the shy one" or "the difficult one." Children live up to the roles we hand them, and they carry those roles long after the toy is forgotten. I try to describe what they do, not who they are. 

5. One-on-one time, even when it's ten minutes. 
This is the one that changed the most. A short stretch of my full attention, with no phone and no sibling, does more than any rule I've tried. 

I think about the long game a lot. Siblings can grow up as each other's closest support, or as strangers who share a surname and a few holidays. A lot of that is decided in the small, loud, ordinary moments at home. 

I won't get it right every day. But I'd like them to know that someone always has their back, and that it starts with the person across the dinner table. 

How do you handle it at home? I'd love to hear what's worked for you. 

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.